Plagiarism

As a member of Brigham Young University — Idaho, it is useful to remind ourselves of two important facts: that most of our tuition is provided by tithe payers, and that we all signed the honor code. Hopefully, these two things will dissuade us from cheating. That being said, it is worthwhile to spend a couple minutes/pages on the subject.

What is cheating?

First, many may not know what exactly constitutes cheating. This is understandable. On one extreme, there is a student working in complete isolation on each assignment, not daring to look at the internet or even the textbook for help on his/her assignments. This clearly is not cheating. On the other extreme, there is a student copying work which he/she does not even understand. Clearly this is cheating. Everything else is a huge gray area.

If you want to forever free yourself from being accused of cheating, the path is actually very simple: cite! On every school assignment and with everything you do in the workplace, give credit where credit is due. Declare who you worked with. Include a citation from the internet source you worked with. Attribute ideas to the person or source that inspired you. These do not have to be official IEEE or MLA citations; just describe in a few words how you got help. If you always do this, no one can ever accuse you of cheating! They may accuse you of getting too much help or not fulfilling the objectives laid out in the assignment, but that is not an honor violation.

Why cheating is a big deal

I would like to present a story that Br. Helfrich had while working in industry long before becoming a professor at BYU-Idaho.

I was working at Microsoft on the Word development team. We needed another developer on the team so we started interviewing. One candidate was from the an overseas university and had a stellar resume. I mean her resume floated a few inches above my desk and hummed every time I looked at it. She looked to be a great fit for my team. When I met her we went through a few “welcome” questions. I then asked her to write the code to find the length of a string. This, of course, is a function that you should be able to write today. Unfortunately, this interview candidate had no idea where to begin. “Well,” I thought, “I got 56 minutes of a one hour interview to kill.” I started asking her about her flight, what she thinks of the weather, and her favorite types of food. I mean, I was really struggling with things to talk with her about. Finally, she asked “this interview is not going the way I expect.” To this I replied, “That is right! We write code here and you can’t!” She protested, “But my resume says I can write code.” I replied, “Well, your resume is a lie. I can give you another coding problem, but I don’t think you will do any better.”

The worst thing I could have done for this girl was to give her the job. She would get fired in a few months and it would be much more painful than sending her back home after this interview. That is the way things go in situations like this. The longer you put off the inevitable, the worse it gets. What should have happened is that she shouldn’t have graduated. Better yet, someone should have failed her in a class long ago. Perhaps she lied on her resume. Perhaps someone did her a “favor” by passing her when she did not deserve it. Perhaps she cheated! Whatever the case, it would have been much less painful for her to have been caught years ago rather than in my office that Tuesday morning.

It may seem like you are jumping through hoops to pass this class or graduate. This is not true! You are here to learn valuable skills that will be essential in the workplace. If you cheat in class, you are only digging a huge hole for yourself that will be difficult to climb out of. In the end, you are only cheating yourself. You need to learn marketable skills regardless of what your grades say and regardless of what your professor does. It is completely up to you!

One final thought. Imagine that you have graduated, got a great job, have a wonderful spouse and family, and just signed mortgage on a new house. You walk through the front door one evening and tell your spouse, “My life is a lie. I don’t actually have any skills because I cheated/lied in college. I just got fired because my manager found out but, don’t worry, I got another job at Burger King.” You need to do everything in your power today to make sure you do not have to say that to your spouse.

Being an accomplice

One more thing. If you post your solutions to a homework assignment on the internet (including GitHub), then you are an accomplice to cheating. You are helping others stray from the strait and narrow path. Please do your part to make cheating as hard as possible for others.